Hi @martin,
This is what I get when everything works. The Blofeld is connected to the E1 directly.
11:12:12.383 processElectraSysex::logger enabled: logLevel=3
11:12:14.686 Midi::processSysex: matched response: responseId=0
11:12:14.689 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=58, byteValue=1, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=122, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.690 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=35, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=44, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.691 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=19, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=37, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.692 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=3, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=29, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.693 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=49, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=49, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.695 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=40, byteValue=4, extractedValue=4 to parameterNumber=46, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=4
11:12:14.696 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=24, byteValue=37, extractedValue=37 to parameterNumber=39, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=37
11:12:14.697 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=8, byteValue=2, extractedValue=2 to parameterNumber=31, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=2
11:12:14.698 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=34, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=43, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.699 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=18, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=36, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.700 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=2, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=28, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.701 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=42, byteValue=5, extractedValue=5 to parameterNumber=105, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=5
11:12:14.703 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=26, byteValue=3, extractedValue=3 to parameterNumber=104, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=3
11:12:14.705 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=10, byteValue=1, extractedValue=1 to parameterNumber=103, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=1
11:12:14.706 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=11, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=34, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.707 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=27, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=41, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.708 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=43, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=48, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.709 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=41, byteValue=127, extractedValue=127 to parameterNumber=47, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=127
11:12:14.711 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=25, byteValue=58, extractedValue=58 to parameterNumber=40, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=58
11:12:14.713 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=9, byteValue=127, extractedValue=127 to parameterNumber=33, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=127
11:12:14.714 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=1, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=27, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.715 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=17, byteValue=52, extractedValue=52 to parameterNumber=35, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=52
11:12:14.716 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=33, byteValue=52, extractedValue=52 to parameterNumber=42, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=52
11:12:14.717 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=58, byteValue=1, extractedValue=1 to parameterNumber=126, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=1
11:12:14.718 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=50, byteValue=2, extractedValue=2 to parameterNumber=175, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=2
11:12:14.719 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=51, byteValue=91, extractedValue=91 to parameterNumber=50, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=91
11:12:14.720 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=30, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=130, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.722 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=14, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=131, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.725 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=71, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=54, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.727 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=67, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=60, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.728 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=65, byteValue=62, extractedValue=62 to parameterNumber=58, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=62
11:12:14.730 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=63, byteValue=76, extractedValue=76 to parameterNumber=56, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=76
11:12:14.732 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=61, byteValue=127, extractedValue=127 to parameterNumber=52, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=127
11:12:14.734 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=5, byteValue=96, extractedValue=96 to parameterNumber=114, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=96
11:12:14.735 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=21, byteValue=96, extractedValue=96 to parameterNumber=116, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=96
11:12:14.737 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=37, byteValue=96, extractedValue=96 to parameterNumber=118, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=96
11:12:14.738 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=56, byteValue=1, extractedValue=1 to parameterNumber=51, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=1
11:12:14.740 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=53, byteValue=1, extractedValue=1 to parameterNumber=65, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=1
11:12:14.743 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=6, byteValue=2, extractedValue=2 to parameterNumber=111, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=2
11:12:14.744 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=22, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=113, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.746 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=38, byteValue=5, extractedValue=5 to parameterNumber=112, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=5
11:12:14.747 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=7, byteValue=22, extractedValue=22 to parameterNumber=30, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=22
11:12:14.748 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=23, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=38, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.750 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=39, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=45, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.752 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=62, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=53, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.754 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=64, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=57, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.755 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=66, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=59, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.757 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=68, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=61, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.759 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=72, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=55, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.760 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=59, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=121, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.762 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=69, byteValue=64, extractedValue=64 to parameterNumber=62, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=64
11:12:14.764 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=32, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=101, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.766 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=48, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=102, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.767 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=16, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=100, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.769 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=4, byteValue=66, extractedValue=66 to parameterNumber=115, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=66
11:12:14.771 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=20, byteValue=66, extractedValue=66 to parameterNumber=117, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=66
11:12:14.772 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=36, byteValue=66, extractedValue=66 to parameterNumber=119, type=sysex resulting in parameterValue=66
11:12:14.774 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=57, byteValue=55, extractedValue=55 to parameterNumber=5, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=55
11:12:14.775 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extraction rule: byte=78, byteValue=0, extractedValue=0 to parameterNumber=69, type=cc7 resulting in parameterValue=0
11:12:14.777 Midi::applyRulesValues: applying extr…
Here is an example where the Blofeld does not respond to the patch request. I tried using the USB Hub, then back to a direct connection. It might be the presence of the Midihub that causes the issues, even after its removed and the instrument is attached directly. I will test that further.
Other Info
- I typically have to unplug and insert the Blofeld after rebooting the the E1 as it doesn’t automatically detect there is an instrument attached.
- I use the reboot option on the E1 between tests
11:26:27.732 processElectraSysex::logger enabled: logLevel=3
11:27:33.115 CustomWriter: cannot delete file: ctrlv2/config4.cfg
11:27:44.862 CustomWriter: cannot delete file: ctrlv2/config4.cfg
11:27:50.756 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=100
11:27:51.057 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=112
11:27:51.759 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=100
11:27:52.260 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=88
11:27:52.560 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=76
11:27:52.760 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=88
11:27:54.566 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=100
11:27:54.867 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=112
11:27:55.430 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=100
11:27:55.831 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=88
11:28:33.540 Config::getUsbHostAssignmentPort: product match: productName=Blofeld
11:28:33.543 Config::getUsbHostAssignmentPort: ports defined: productName=Blofeld
11:28:33.544 USB port: 0, name: Blofeld -> to port: 0
11:28:33.545 Config::getUsbHostAssignmentPresetId: device=Blofeld, presetId=255
11:28:52.080 SysexApi::process: application system call
11:28:52.081 processElectraSysex::logger enabled: logLevel=3
11:29:02.446 CustomWriter: cannot delete file: ctrlv2/config4.cfg
11:29:30.179 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=100
11:29:30.380 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=112
11:29:30.705 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=100
11:29:30.804 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=88
11:29:31.205 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=76
11:29:31.505 ElectraMidi: processMidi: Control change midi message: parameter=27, value=64
11:29:45.447 Config::getUsbHostAssignmentPort: product match: productName=Blofeld
11:29:45.450 Config::getUsbHostAssignmentPort: ports defined: productName=Blofeld
11:29:45.451 USB port: 0, name: Blofeld -> to port: 0
11:29:45.452 Config::getUsbHostAssignmentPresetId: device=Blofeld, presetId=255
You can see me testing the midi communication, there are CC msgs comming in, yet the patch request doesn’t reply.
I obseved that sometimes pressing the patch request button results in none of the IO ports flashing on the E1 with no values in the debugger. Also, the IO indicators do sometimes flash with also with no values shown in the debugger.
11:53 am: The E1+Blofeld are now in the state where bidirectional midi is working but the patch request does not work. The IO labels don’t flash and the MIDI light on the Blofeld doesn’t flash either. No USB Hub is in use. The Blofeld is attached directly.
- Turning off the E1 (by unplugging it), starting it again, reattaching the Blofeld via USB to the HOST port so that the E1 detects it - Bidirectional Midi works but Patch Request does not
- Turning both the E1 and the Blofeld off, and starting them E1 then the Blofeld also has the same issue.
12:02 PM: It took 4 attempt to get the Blofeld patch to load onto the E1 however after it did work everything worked, Bidirectional MIDI CC and SysEx / Patch Request. However the same loop exists. If I reboot the E1 Patch Requests stop working. No USB Hub was used for this part of the test.