Hello! I watched your review, and it provides a really in-depth analysis of the device, along with an interesting share of your experiences within your development environment.
While I agree with some of your points, my experience and feelings about this device differ. I primarily use the Electra One for creating CC knobs to control parameters in Ableton. Even though this is a “simplified” experience compared to what the Electra can fully accomplish, it provides a joyful and straightforward experience, especially when compared to other brands’ devices. Having tested many of them, I can confidently say that, for me, it offers the best experience I’ve had with autonomous MIDI device controllers (with real knobs!! ) .
I own Launchpads, Push 2, BCF2000, Midi Fighters Twisters, Streamdeck,ipad etc. My best combination is Electra One and Streamdecks. The Electra One is even easier for creating CC templates than the Streamdeck. Creating MIDI buttons on the Streamdeck with the wonderful Trevliga plugin can be quite time-consuming, especially since you cannot work on multiple icons simultaneously.
On the Electra, you can edit/select multiple knobs/faders, modify them, copy/paste them, and change colors, which saves a lot of time. The web interface is excellently designed, allowing you to create simple templates quickly. I find the E1 web editor to be intuitive and easy to use. Additionally, if I need to delve deeper, I can! Using some simple Lua code is very straightforward, and there are plenty of examples available thanks to the community and Martin.
I do not believe this device is for a niche market; in my opinion, it is the most user-friendly interface for creating knobs and assigning CCs, outperforming other products. There are very few options for an autonomous MIDI controller with a large touchscreen, and the Electra One stands out. If you want or need to dive deep, you can. Personally, I have not explored all the depths of this device and yet, I am thrilled with the “simple” yet powerful functionalities I have achieved with the Electra One. I believe I will never need to go beyond what the editor offers in its simplest form, which already surpasses other gear by a significant margin.