If I define a list with overlay values, then whatever list item /value I choose, the control always sends out the value ‘0’ over MIDI. The controls does respond correctly to incoming MIDI value updates, jumping to the correct list item
@jhh, I assume you are running the beta firmware. Pls note I am still busy with that version.
Yes, that’s the version I was using
There’s v4.1.5b on beta. The lists should work there as expected.
No, unfortunately not. They no longer end out only zero’s, but I have lists like 12db=0, 24db=127 or looping over 0, 14, 28 etc, and those values are still not sent out (the lists DO respond properly to incoming values though). Have a look at my AutoFilter2 preset to check if you are seeing what I am seeing. For example these are the midi messages exchanged when I first select 24 then 12 db in autofilter in Live and then do the same on the E1 mini. Note how this sends the value 1 (not 7F):
I have a problem that may be related, although I am not on the beta. My JX-3P preset uses two state lists with custom overlays (bitmaps) for two CC controls that switch ENV polarity for DCO and VCF, and one CC control that changes the VCA between ENV and Gate modes. These controls work fine in use, but the ‘set all defaults’ function ignores the chosen default value (64), and instead sends zero.
The preset loads with them showing the correct default values, (positive envelopes and VCA in ENV mode), but ‘set all defaults’ function will invert the envelopes and set the VCA to gate mode.
My Mini category preset has layouts for both the Mini and the E1, and both devices have same incorrect behaviour.
I also use three and four state list controls with bitmaps for the waveforms, but they have a default value of zero, so the issue does not affect them.
Hi @martin Any progress on this, or is there something wrong at my end?
I have been making changes in that area. Mostly to add support to “modulate” all control types. Currently, only proportional controls, such as faders, were supported. Whole release is taking a bit longer because I decided to make major update of the automated tests. Which basically meant to make it possible to compile most of the E1 sources on the computer. It is basically completed now. I will upload the latest firmware to beta today and will start preparing everything for the public release. I am sorry for clumsy communication - it has been quite hectic here due to non-E1 stuff.
I did use your preset to review one of the latest betas and it looks ok.